Mystery Painting in KHS Archives

Home Forums 20th Century Mystery Painting in KHS Archives

Tagged: 

Viewing 13 reply threads
  • Author
    Posts
    • #4141
      ndembowski
      Keymaster

        We recently moved a large portion of the KHS archives into our new headquarters at Edgehill.  There are some fascinating items to investigate.  One thing that caught my eye was this painting:

        It is obviously in terrible shape, which is too bad.  But it depicts a scene rarely seen in color.  That is a view looking northeast toward Spuyten Duyvil Hill with the Spuyten Duyvil train station in the foreground and the old Villa Rosa Bonheur building on the upper right.

        A view of the Villa Rosa Bonheur apartment building

        The painting is unsigned.  The car looks to be a 1920 to 1930s era vehicle:

        Rather than looking at an oncoming train, the folks at the station seem to be looking and gesturing toward the woods or the Villa Rosa Bonheur…

        And there is definitely something happening in the woods beyond the station (although I am struggling to figure out what exactly).  It makes me think that this painting is not merely a landscape but might be depicting a specific event:

        Scene of Figures Moving in the Woods of Spuyten Duyvil

         

      • #4142
        Thomas Casey
        Participant

          Yes….Passengers are running for the train and everyone is cheering them on.

        • #4143
          Thomas Casey
          Participant
          • #4144
            Peter Ostrander
            Participant

              I have always believed it was painted by Charlotte Livingston ( B 1898) who also was a long time trustee of KHS. She lived her life in Kingsbridge and married to Francis vander veer Kughler who was a professional artist.

              It looks to me as if the women  in yellow dress running down to greet the man in brown suit with grey hat. It is the early 20th  C. painting. Today she would likely be chasing someone who just stole her bag.

              The car could date the painting if someone can put a date as to the style.

              Most of the people look to be wearing face masks which would fit for the flu pandemic. 1918-1919 but the car  is not of that period.

               

               

               

               

               

               

               

            • #4164
              jbakerjonathan
              Participant

                The car might be a mid to late ‘20’s Hupmobile…or not. Fedora hats became popular in the mid ‘20’s as did just below the knee dresses and coats for women. The Villa Rosa Bonheur house was constructed in 1924. I’d say the painting possibly dates to that time.   I don’t see facemasks.

              • #4165
                jbakerjonathan
                Participant

                  There is a building  in the upper left section of the painting with a man coming down the stairs.  It appears that the apartment building (2465 Palisade Ave) is in that location today and was build in 1958.  Does anyone have information concerning the old building?

                • #4184
                  Kapette
                  Participant

                    Quick note on the face masks perception. I can see why they may look that way but it’s just a style of painting shadows thrown by hats on their faces, to highlight light/dark places using rough strokes. I love the painting.

                  • #4185
                    jbakerjonathan
                    Participant

                      I agree.  I have a friend who paints in this style.

                    • #4186
                      Peter Ostrander
                      Participant

                        They must have liked the pandemic  8:0

                      • #4187
                        Anne Keary
                        Participant

                          How about 2475 Palisade??

                        • #4188
                          jbakerjonathan
                          Participant

                            Anne, did you mean to type 2465 Palisade?  2475 seems to be too far to the left of the station and the Villa Rosa Bonheur.

                          • #4189
                            Anne Keary
                            Participant

                              2475 –It is Villa Victoria

                            • #4286
                              Elliot Feldman
                              Participant

                                I got a second opinion on the car from a friend of mine who’s interested – he guesses a Ford Model A or B, so 1927-34, which doesn’t narrow down the potential date much more than the other info we have, but I thought it might be of interest.

                              • #4287
                                John Tierney
                                Participant

                                  Thanks to all! My son, Luke (who did volunteer work for KHS when he was in high school), lived in the Villa Rosa Bonheur from 2014 until it was sold. We loved it — we had a duplex, so that my son had the second floor to himself. It was in pretty bad shape at the end — the last winter, when most of the other tenants had moved out, the oil furnace was leaking so many fumes (through a patchwork of duct tape on the furnace’s seams) that we told the new owner to shut it down and buy us electric heaters. The new owner directed us to a web site with detailed floor plans for renovating the building, but they were odd — the plans gave our apartment an extra balcony leaving the bigger apartment next door without a balcony, which didn’t seem to make any sense (and the owner didn’t really seem to know what was in the plans). Then, of course, they just tore down the building anyway. I was sorry to see it go, but I’m glad that so many people get to enjoy the views (and the two-minute walk to the train platform) the new building, the Henry.

                              Viewing 13 reply threads
                              • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.